/dhyan

dhyān

effortless, continuous attention

the mind flows toward an object without interruption, without management, without a sense of "you" doing the attending. it emerges from dharana — the practice of placing attention deliberately.

dharana is effort. dhyan is what remains when the effort is no longer needed.

the practical axis:

dharana = operational work (agent online, error-monitoring intact, effort appropriate)

dhyan = creative work (agent recedes, critic dissolves, flow self-sustains)

this is attention training for cognitive work — not retreat phenomenology.

what is dhyan?

dhyan is the seventh limb of patanjali's ashtanga yoga. it sits in the internal triad:

dharana
attention placed
effortful localization
dhyana
attention flows
effortless continuity
samadhi
object shines
subject-object collapse

the operative term is pratyaya-ekatanata — "single-extendedness." not single-pointedness (that's dharana). single-streamedness. continuity without intervention.

the prerequisite: dharana

before dhyan, you train concentration.

how to practice dharana:

  1. choose an object — breath sensation at the nostrils is standard
  2. place attention there
  3. when attention wanders, notice
  4. return
  5. repeat

the return is the practice. wandering is not failure — it's the rep.

object selection:

breath — nostril sensationdefault, always available
visual — point, flame, after-imagestrong anchoring
somatic — body region, sensationgrounding
auditory — mantra, ambient soundverbal minds

pick one. stay with it across sessions.

signs of progress:

  • gap frequency: many → few
  • gap duration: long → short
  • return speed: slow → immediate
  • effort: heavy → light

when attention rests on object with minimal management, dharana is established.

common adjustments:

  • can't find object — make it coarser (whole breath vs. nostril tip)
  • constant forgetting — shorten sessions, increase frequency
  • dullness — eyes open, slight uplift, earlier in day
  • agitation — longer exhale, lower gaze, coarser object

entering dhyan

dhyan is not something you do. it's what happens when you stop doing dharana.

the transition:

with attention stable on object, release the effort of holding it there. don't add anything. don't go deeper. just stop managing.

if attention stays → you're in dhyan.
if attention scatters → return to dharana.

the shift:

  • placing → stop placing → placed
  • holding → release grip → held
  • doing → stop doing → done
  • you → object → object alone

the arrow remains. the archer disappears.

practical cue: when attention is stable on object, ask: what happens if i stop trying?

what you're not doing:

  • not adding anything
  • not going deeper
  • not concentrating harder
  • not switching technique

just: stop.

phenomenology of dhyan

what dhyan feels like:

  • time compresses — sessions feel shorter than clock time
  • sense of "meditating" fades
  • object remains without re-placement
  • background mental noise absent
  • you notice you were in dhyan only after

dharana vs dhyan:

  • effort: present → absent
  • gaps: noticeable → none
  • time: tracked → compressed
  • agent: felt → receding
  • object: held → receiving

the agent question:

dharana: you → attention → object. three things.

dhyan: attention → object. you fade into background.

the difference isn't depth of concentration. it's who's doing it. dharana has an agent. dhyan has a process.

common problems

  • attention scatters when effort stops — dharana not yet stable. more dharana training.
  • dullness, sinking, fog — energy dropped with effort. refresh alertness, shorter sessions.
  • can't release effort — controller habit strong. practice releasing in small doses; it softens.
  • diffuse, dreamy — premature release. establish stronger base first.

the strength question:

effort release before sufficient concentration = sinking. you get diffuse attention, low energy, dreamy dullness. not dhyan — collapse.

dhyan works when concentration is already online. the controller releases, but the momentum continues. like hand off bicycle — works if you're already moving.

practical test: when you release effort, does attention:

stay oriented, just without pushing → dhyan

scatter, sink, fog → premature

dhyan and work

the practical axis:

  • ops (execution, systematic processing) → dharana. settle, then work. stay placed.
  • creative (flow, generative) → dhyan. settle until flow self-sustains, then redirect stream to creative object.

why this mapping:

dharana for ops: agent online. error-monitoring intact. gaps acceptable. effort appropriate — you're doing. metacognition required.

dhyan for creative: agent recedes. critic dissolves. gaps break the stream — continuity is the product. effort counterproductive — you're receiving. metacognition interferes.

failure modes:

  • dharana during creative = excessive editing, critic dominance, stilted output
  • dhyan during ops = missed errors, scattered execution, dream-logic in task management

entry protocol:

for ops: sit briefly, establish access concentration. transition to work. refresh every 90-120 min.

for creative: sit until flow self-sustains. gently introduce creative object. let attention flow toward it without re-engaging controller.

practice summary

  1. dharana: place attention, return when it wanders, repeat
  2. stabilize: gaps few, effort light, object holding
  3. dhyan: stop managing, let attention rest, observe what remains
  4. apply: dharana for ops, dhyan for creative

questions & answers

pre-computed responses for common questions.

on dharana
how long should i practice dharana before attempting dhyan?
no fixed duration. the metric is stability, not time. when gaps between attention-wandering become rare and returns become immediate, dharana is established. for some this takes weeks, for others months. daily practice of 20-30 minutes typically yields workable dharana within 4-8 weeks. don't rush — premature dhyan attempts just produce collapse.
what's the difference between access concentration and dharana?
access concentration (upacara samadhi) is a theravada term for the threshold just before jhana — stable enough that jhana factors can arise, but not yet absorbed. dharana is the yoga darshana term for the effortful placement of attention on object. they overlap significantly. think of dharana as the broader category, access as the mature end of it.
how do i know if my dharana is strong enough?
three markers: (1) you can sustain 5+ minutes without major wandering. (2) when attention wanders, you notice within seconds (not minutes). (3) returning feels easy, not effortful. test: sit with breath at nostrils. if you can maintain continuous contact for 2-3 minutes with only minor wobbles, try releasing effort. if attention stays — dharana is sufficient. if it collapses — continue training.
can i use multiple objects or should i stick with one?
stick with one for building dharana. object-switching prevents the depth of familiarity needed for effortless attention. once dharana is stable, you can experiment with different objects for different purposes. but the training phase benefits from consistency.
what's the relationship between dharana and shamatha?
shamatha means "calming" or "tranquility" — the entire concentration path in buddhist framing. dharana is one stage within concentration development in yoga framing. shamatha encompasses what yoga calls dharana + dhyana + lower samadhi. different taxonomies, overlapping territory.
on the transition
how do i "stop trying" without losing the object?
the object remains because momentum carries it. you've been placing attention there repeatedly — a groove has formed. releasing effort doesn't mean releasing the object. it means releasing the activity of placing. think: you've been pushing a swing. now stop pushing. the swing continues.
what's the difference between releasing effort and becoming dull?
effort-release with maintained clarity = dhyan. effort-release with dimming awareness = dullness (laya). the distinction is energy. in dhyan, alertness remains — you're awake, clear, just not pushing. in dullness, alertness drops — foggy, dreamy, sinking.
can the transition be gradual or is it binary?
both. phenomenologically it often feels binary — you're either placing or you're not. but the underlying stability is gradual. you don't flip a switch; you cultivate conditions until the flip becomes possible. the moment of release is binary, the development is gradual.
what if i keep oscillating between dharana and dhyan?
normal. this is the training. you release, attention stays (dhyan), then you notice you're in dhyan, that noticing recruits the controller, now you're doing dharana again. the oscillation is the edge where learning happens. don't fight the oscillation — observe it.
is shinzen young's "do nothing" the same as entering dhyan?
close but not identical. do nothing targets effort-release directly: when you notice intention to control, let it go. but dhyan traditionally has an object; do nothing is objectless. the mechanism is the same (controller drops out), the context differs. for work-dhyan, use do nothing with creative object already present.
on dhyan phenomenology
what does "agent receding" actually feel like?
less "i am attending" and more "attending is happening." the sense of being the one who's doing it fades. you might notice this only retrospectively — you surface and realize "i" wasn't there in the usual way. the absence is known by contrast when the agent returns.
how do i know i'm in dhyan vs. just relaxed concentration?
dhyan has continuity without management. relaxed concentration might still have gaps you're filling, effort you're applying — just less of it. the test: are you doing anything? if the stream is self-sustaining and you're not maintaining it, that's dhyan. time distortion is a reliable marker — if 20 minutes felt like 5, you were likely in dhyan.
why does time compress in dhyan?
time perception requires reference points — moments of self-checking, mental noting, comparison. dhyan has fewer of these interruptions. continuous flow without punctuation compresses into felt brevity. also: the self that tracks time is the same self that recedes.
can dhyan be maintained with eyes open?
yes, though harder initially. eyes open provides more sensory input, more potential distraction. but with stable dharana base, dhyan can occur with eyes open, especially if gaze is soft and environment is low-stimulus. useful for work-dhyan — you need to see the creative object.
what's the difference between dhyan and flow state?
high overlap. flow describes task-absorption with reduced self-consciousness, time distortion, intrinsic motivation. dhyan is the same phenomenology framed as attention-mode rather than task-engagement. flow is often discovered accidentally; dhyan is cultivated deliberately. the felt experience is nearly identical.
on work application
how do i maintain dhyan while doing creative work?
you don't maintain it — you let it maintain itself while redirecting the stream. enter dhyan via sitting practice, then gently introduce the creative object before fully surfacing. the stream continues flowing; the object changes. if the controller re-engages strongly, you've dropped back to dharana. that's fine — continue working, return to dhyan-entry when you notice.
what if my creative work requires critical judgment?
separate the phases. generative phase = dhyan-compatible (flow, receiving, critic absent). evaluative phase = dharana-compatible (agent online, judgment active). don't try to generate and evaluate simultaneously — that's neither state done well. create, then assess.
can i toggle between dharana and dhyan during a work session?
yes, and you likely will naturally. creative burst (dhyan) → review/adjust (dharana) → next burst (dhyan). the skill is recognizing which mode you're in and whether it matches what you need.
how long does post-dhyan clarity last?
variable. deep dhyan can leave clarity lasting hours. light dhyan might fade within 20-30 minutes. the "post-jhana afterglow" is real — residual equanimity, lowered mental noise, enhanced pattern recognition. plan important insight work for this window.
what's the minimum effective dose for work optimization?
for ops: 5-10 minutes of settling into dharana before work, refresh every 90-120 minutes. for creative: 15-20 minutes or until you feel the flow establish. even 2-3 minutes of breath focus before work measurably reduces subsequent mind-wandering. something beats nothing.
on depth and progression
does dhyan have levels or is it binary?
native yoga tradition treats dhyan as threshold, not ladder. you're flowing or you're not. but depth exists implicitly: the stream can be more or less complete, the agent more or less receded. for work purposes, two-point discrimination suffices: am i flowing? am i about to lose work-capacity?
what's the relationship between dhyan and jhana?
jhana (pali) and dhyana (sanskrit) share etymology — same word, different traditions. buddhist jhana is a ladder of discrete states with specific factors. yoga dhyana is a mode of continuous attention without enumerated stages. the phenomenology overlaps; the frameworks differ.
how does dhyan relate to formless states?
in yoga: dhyan on formless objects (space, consciousness, nothingness) leads toward formless samadhi. in buddhism: formless jhanas are a separate track. both agree: attention can rest on subtle or objectless "objects." the progression is gross → subtle → formless → cessation.
what comes after dhyan — how do i approach samadhi?
samadhi arises when dhyan becomes complete. you don't "do" samadhi — it's what remains when the last traces of doer dissolve. for approach: continue dhyan, don't grasp at samadhi. grasping re-engages the controller. let the stream deepen naturally.
can dhyan lead to insight or is it purely concentration?
dhyan itself is concentration (samatha). but it creates conditions for insight (vipassana). the still, continuous mind sees what scattered mind cannot. many traditions combine: stabilize in dhyan, then apply attention to impermanence. pure dhyan without inquiry leads to deep states but not necessarily liberation.
on obstacles
what if i can never seem to release the controller?
the controller softens with practice, not force. forcing release is still controlling. two approaches: (1) extend dharana training until release happens naturally. (2) practice releasing in small doses — let go for 3 seconds, then resume. the controller is habit, not necessity.
how do i distinguish dhyan from dissociation?
dhyan: alert, clear, present, continuous awareness of object. dissociation: foggy, disconnected, absence of content, defensive escape. in dhyan you're more present, not less. the object is vivid. dissociation is a gap — you surface and don't know where you were.
what if dhyan produces anxiety or fear?
sometimes relaxing defenses surfaces suppressed material. options: (1) titrate — shorter sessions. (2) ground more thoroughly before practice. (3) work with the anxiety in dharana before attempting release. (4) if trauma-related, work with a trauma-informed therapist.
can trauma affect dharana/dhyan practice?
yes. trauma disrupts the nervous system's capacity for stillness. hypervigilance makes sustained attention difficult. trauma-sensitive modifications: eyes open, shorter duration, emphasis on grounding, co-regulation. healing trauma often makes practice more accessible.
what if i experience strange sensations or visions?
normal at certain stages. as concentration deepens, unusual perceptual phenomena arise — lights, vibrations, body distortions, imagery. these are called "nimitta" in buddhist tradition. they indicate deepening concentration but aren't the goal. don't chase them, don't fear them. return to object.
on integration
how does dhyan relate to daily life awareness?
dhyan is formal practice; daily awareness is the integration. skills transfer: the capacity for sustained attention, reduced reactivity, observer perspective. the goal isn't to be in dhyan while driving — it's for dhyan training to upgrade baseline attention quality.
can dharana/dhyan training change baseline attention?
yes, with sufficient practice. studies show meditators have enhanced attentional control, reduced mind-wandering, faster attentional switching even outside meditation. this is trait change, not just state induction. weeks to months of consistent practice for measurable trait effects.
what's the relationship between dhyan and non-dual awareness?
dhyan is dualistic — there's still attention and object, even if subtly. non-dual awareness (rigpa, turiya, sahaja) is when the subject-object structure itself dissolves. some traditions see dhyan as preparation for non-dual recognition; others see it as orthogonal to concentration.
how do contemplative traditions other than yoga frame this?
theravada buddhism: jhana sequence with emphasis on factors. zen: shikantaza (just sitting). tibetan: shamatha-vipashyana. taoism: zuowang (sitting forgetting). christian mysticism: contemplative prayer. the phenomenology converges; the framing differs.
what does neuroscience say about these states?
research shows: decreased default mode network activity, increased global functional connectivity, altered eeg signatures, reduced within-network modularity. studies by sacchet, brewer, davidson and others. the states are real, measurable, and involve distinct neural configurations from ordinary waking consciousness.

dhyan is the foundation for insight. the still, continuous mind sees what the scattered mind cannot.

for holon research's work bridging contemplative practice and ai alignment: dhyan is the base state from which self-structure becomes observable. without this stability, investigation remains conceptual. with it, direct examination becomes possible.

dhyan is attention. attention is all we need.

/